Millennial Finances Why They Struggle (Despite Being the Most Highly Educated Generation in History

Millennial Finances: Why They Struggle (Despite Being the Most Highly Educated Generation in History)

Millennials are buried under a mountain of cheap credit and inflated tuition

By many reports, the millennial generation is the most educated generation in US history —and by some stretch. Take a look at this graph from Pew Research.

Pattern for job security image

Yet, they have a problem. Despite all this higher education, they have the highest levels of unemployment of any work demographic and they make 20 percent less than their parents did at the same stage of life.

On top of all this, they also have a crushing amount of student loan debt. As Inc. Magazine reports:

Americans owe more than $1.2 trillion in student loans, and Millennials are carrying most of that debt. And they’ll be carrying it for a long, long time, according to a new survey of 1,000 Millennials by ORC International, commissioned by the PR firm PadillaCRT. Almost two thirds of respondents reported having at least $10,000 in student debt. More than a third said they owed more than $30,000.

The financial fallout of the coronavirus pandemic will only make this debt burden worse.

Some people think that cutting back on avocado toast will solve these problems for millennials. But it goes much deeper than a few simple splurges.

The double Millennial financial whammy

In many ways, millennials are victims of a cruel double whammy: systemic debt and asset bubbles and an antiquated education on how money works.

Charles Hugh Smith published an important blog post in 2017 called “Will the Crazy Global Debt Bubble Ever End?”. In the post, he detailed how most consumer debt is not backed by physical assets but instead by the ability of the borrower to pay the debt.

In recent years, near-zero interest rates have led to continued expansion of consumer debt. In fact, in 2020 it sat at $14.15 trillion. That’s higher than it was during the third quarter of 2008, which was right when the financial world collapsed.

Of course, during this time income has not gone up. As Smith shows, inflation adjusted median household income has been flat since 1998, and those in the bottom 90% of earners have actually seen their incomes go down.

So, we continue to see increasing amounts of debt but no growth in income to service it. How does this continue? By settling artificially low interest rates from the central banks.

This is what the banks wanted. It gives the appearance of growth without actually creating true growth.

Millennial finances stretched... but not in pursuit of a lavish lifestyle

In the meantime, as Smith points out, “state-protected cartels” have increased their prices to astronomical levels.

Pattern for job security image

You’ll notice that two of the very basics needed for life: food and shelter have seen 50% inflation since 1996, while clothing has held steady at a little under 0%.

College tuition and textbooks are 200% more expensive. That’s astounding—and criminal. It’s no wonder the most educated generation in US history is also the one with the most money problems.

For decades, the cardinal rule of success in the US was to go to college and get a good degree. This was the foundational step to then getting a high paying job, buying a house, and investing for retirement in a 401(k).

These are, of course, all old rules of money—they are financial lies.

Millennials buying into into financial lies

The millennial generation bought into these financial lies one hundred percent. That is why they are both the most educated generation and the worse off financially. In the time while they were getting their college education, the cost was inflating at astronomical levels while the cost of living was going up, employment was going down, and incomes were shrinking.

In the meantime, the cost of cheap consumer goods like TVs and smartphones plummeted, thanks to cheap overseas labor and production. The perfect storm happened. Millennials racked up both consumer debt thanks to cheap credit card rates and assumed their highly-inflated education costs would pay off in high paying jobs to cover the debt.

It is working out quite differently. The result, as USA Today reports, is that while 48% of millennials feel optimistic about their financial future, which is higher that both gen X (37%) and baby boomers (22%), they also have the highest levels of stress regarding their finances. They stress four hours on average per week about money, compared to two hours for gen X and one hour for baby boomers.

And as CNBC reports, millennials have big regrets when it comes to money:

Pattern for job security image

How Generation Z approaches finances differently than millennials

Generation Z, the little brothers and sisters of the millennials have watched from the stands—and they want to do things different.

According to a 2017 study by the Center for Generational Kinetics, the youngest generation coming into adulthood approaches money very differently than preceding generations.

For one, they “avoid debt like the plague.” When it comes to college, they’ve learned their lesson. Most seek education that won’t leave them in debt. Most plan to work while attending college to avoid debt, and a quarter of them plan to use savings to pay the costs.

This debt avoidance also gives birth to a high value on saving. With many Gen Z folks still in their teens,12% have already started saving for retirement and 35% say they will start in their twenties.

Perhaps most surprising is how Get Z plans to fund retirement: “At least 52% in the Center for Generational Kinetics study said they planned to pay for retirement with personal savings, 28% will continue to work and 26% will depend upon government assistance.”

So, while Gen Z is learning a valuable lesson about the old rules of money—that going to college isn’t a great investment—they are doubling down on two others: save money and stay out of debt. They are also buying into the myth that a job provides financial security.

And with the pandemic prolonging, it appears that even these financial walls are crumbling. Gen Z by far has the highest unemployment rate in the country bouncing around in the 20% ranges and they are entering the job market in a massive recession….just like their millennial brothers and sisters did in the early 2000s. What will become of them remains to be seen.

How millennials can change their financial problems

Still these are at least green shoots in the financial literacy landscape of America. If the monopoly that is higher education in this country is broken by a generation that refuses to play the game, that can force a lot of change that is positive.

For both the millennials and Generation Z, it’s not too late, but it starts with financial education and understanding how money works in today’s economy. My blog post, “15 Must Have Financial Education Lessons to Gain True Financial Literacy”, is a good place to start.

Original publish date: June 12, 2017